1909 American Cup

The 1909 American Cup was the annual open cup held by the American Football Association.

American Cup Bracket

Home teams listed on top of bracket

  Quarterfinals Semifinals Finals
                           
  NJ  Paterson True Blues 2  
RI  Howard & Bullough 0  
  NJ  Paterson True Blues 4  
  NJ  Jersey A.C. 3  
NJ  Jersey A.C. 1-2*
  NY  Brooklyn Camerons 1-0  
    NJ  Paterson True Blues 1-2*
  NJ  Clark A.A. 1-1
  NJ  Clark A.A. 1  
NY  Clan MacDonald 0  
  NJ  Clark A.A. 2
  MA  Fall River Rovers 0  
MA  Fall River Rovers 6
  NJ  Newark F.C. 1  

(*): replay after tied match

Final

April 18, 1909
Paterson True Blues (NJ) 1–1 East Newark Clark A.A. (NJ) Harrison, New Jersey

Replay

May 2, 1909
Paterson True Blues (NJ) 2–1 East Newark Clark A.A. (NJ) Harrison Oval
Attendance: 10,000
Referee: James Nesbitt

Paterson True Blues: GK Garside, DF Murray, McClellan, MF MacInstri, Stewart, Chambers, FW Spindler, Fletcher, McWinnie, Gilmour, Donechie.
Clark A.A.: GK Hunt, DF Tomar, T.Fisher, MF Lone, Porter, Foster, FW C.Fisher, Maitland, Martin, Young, Neilson.